Spice Bread Stuffing - This recipe is the easiest one to make. If you don't have any cooking skill, I would recommend making this dish for the achievment. All it takes is Spice Bread and Autumnal Herbs. Spice Bread is one of the first recipes learned in cooking and only takes Simple Flour and Mild Spices to create. Both of those ingredients can be bought from the nearby cooking vendor.
Slow Roasted Turkey - Of course to make a Slow Roasted Turkey you'll a Wild Turkey! You can hunt them either in Elwynn Forest or in Tirisfal Glades. You'll also need 2 jars of Honey and Autumnal Herbs.
You'll need to have cooking skill of at least 280 to prepare all the dishes!